Some pains don’t show on the outside.
You might be able to serve, smile, and say “I’m fine,” while inside you feel:
- Exhausted for no clear reason
- Anxious about everything
- Numb, heavy, or unable to enjoy what you used to love
- Afraid that if anyone knew what was going on inside, they’d back away—or judge your faith
This is written for you, and for those who love someone in this place.
We’ll walk through:
- Distinguishing spiritual struggles from clinical conditions
- Debunking myths and stigma about Christians and mental illness
- The role of lament, prayer, and Scripture in emotional distress
- When and why to seek professional counseling or medication
- How family and church can support without over‑spiritualizing
- Pastoral limits: what pastors can and cannot offer ethically
- A holistic view of body, mind, soul, and relationships
- Recommended Christian books for further study
✨ Discover FAQs of Faith Mobile App! ✨Looking for a convenient way to access all your favorite faith-based content? Introducing the FAQs of Faith mobile app, your go-to resource that combines insightful and inspiring content from Faith Answers Press LLC into one easy-to-use platform. Whether you’re seeking answers to faith questions, daily inspiration, or spiritual growth resources, our app has it all. 📲 Download now and start your journey! Click on FAQs of Faith
1. Spiritual Struggles vs. Clinical Conditions
Every part of you—body, mind, emotions, and spirit—is affected by the fall (Genesis 3). That means all our struggles are, in some sense, spiritual. But not every struggle is only spiritual.
Spiritual struggles
Spiritual struggles may look like:
- Ongoing patterns of sin (anger, lust, bitterness)
- Doubt about God’s goodness or existence
- Prayerlessness, spiritual dryness, or apathy
- Guilt and shame numbing your joy in Christ
These call for:
- Repentance and faith
- Spiritual practices (prayer, Scripture, fellowship, sacraments)
- Wise pastoral care and community
Clinical conditions
Clinical conditions (like major depression, bipolar disorder, anxiety disorders, OCD, PTSD, ADHD, some forms of psychosis) often include:
- Persistent, intense symptoms that affect daily functioning
- Changes in sleep, appetite, energy, concentration
- Physical symptoms (heart racing, stomach issues, panic attacks)
- A sense that the “volume knob” on feelings is stuck on high or low
- Sometimes a family history of similar conditions
These can have:
- Biological / genetic components
- The impact of trauma or chronic stress
- Learned thought patterns
- Spiritual dimensions (how you interpret and respond before God)
Christian counselor Ed Welch often says:
“We are body and spirit together. Wise care will always consider both.”
— Edward T. Welch (paraphrased from multiple works)
So:
- Some spiritual struggles will improve significantly as you grow in repentance, faith, and community.
- Some mental health struggles will also require medical and psychological support, alongside spiritual care.
It’s rarely either/or. It’s usually both/and.
2. Myths and Stigma About Christians and Mental Illness
Sadly, many believers suffer under harmful messages like:
- “Real Christians shouldn’t be depressed.”
- “If you had more faith, you wouldn’t be anxious.”
- “Counselors and medication are for weak people, not for those who trust God.”
These are not biblical.
Myth 1: “Mental illness is always a sign of weak faith.”
The Bible shows godly people in deep emotional distress:
- David: “Why are you cast down, O my soul?” (Psalm 42:5)
- Elijah: “It is enough; now, O Lord, take away my life” (1 Kings 19:4)
- Jeremiah: “Cursed be the day on which I was born!” (Jeremiah 20:14)
- Paul: “We were so utterly burdened beyond our strength that we despaired of life itself.” (2 Corinthians 1:8)
Struggles with despair and anguish do not automatically mean your faith is fake. Often they are part of living in a broken world while clinging to a real Savior.
Myth 2: “If you just pray and read your Bible more, you’ll be fine.”
Prayer and Scripture are vital (we’ll talk about that). But Scripture itself recognizes:
- The need for medicine: “Give strong drink to the one who is perishing, and wine to those in bitter distress” (Proverbs 31:6) – not as ultimate hope, but as practical help.
- The value of skilled help (Exodus 31:1–5; Proverbs often praises wise counselors).
Tim Keller once noted:
“If we believe God works through farmers to feed us, we can believe he works through doctors and counselors to heal us.”
— Timothy Keller (paraphrased)
Myth 3: “Going to counseling or taking medication means you’re not trusting God.”
Seeking help is often an expression of humility and wisdom:
“In an abundance of counselors there is safety.”
(Proverbs 11:14; 15:22)
You trust God when you pray for daily bread—and you still go to work and buy food. In a similar way, you can trust God while:
- Seeing a counselor
- Taking medication when appropriate
- Adjusting lifestyle, sleep, and stress
Faith is not measured by how little help you accept, but by Whom you ultimately rely on.
3. Lament, Prayer, and Scripture in Emotional Distress
God did not wait for you to feel “fixed” before giving you words to cry out. The Bible is full of lament—prayers of pain, confusion, and protest spoken to God, not away from Him.
Lament: Bringing honest sorrow to God
Examples:
- Psalm 13 – “How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever?”
- Psalm 42 – “My tears have been my food day and night.”
- Psalm 88 – Ends with, “Darkness is my closest friend.”
These show:
- God expects seasons when His people feel overwhelmed and confused.
- He gives permission to speak honestly.
- Lament is not unbelief; it is faith that takes pain to God.
You might pray:
“Lord, my mind feels broken. I’m tired of being afraid and sad. I don’t understand why this won’t lift. Have mercy. Hold me when I can’t feel You.”
Prayer: Weak prayers still count
Romans 8:26–27 says:
“We do not know what to pray for as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words.”
When all you can manage is:
- “Help me, Jesus.”
- “Lord, have mercy.”
- Silent tears in God’s presence,
He hears, understands, and prays for you even better than you can for yourself.
Scripture: Anchor, not band‑aid
Scripture is not a quick fix, but a deep anchor:
- Psalms – Give voice to your emotions.
- Lamentations 3 – Grief and hope in tension.
- Matthew 11:28–30 – “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden…”
- Romans 8 – God’s love in suffering; nothing can separate us from Him.
- 1 Peter 5:7 – “Casting all your anxieties on him, because he cares for you.”
You might choose one small passage to sit in for a week, reading and praying it slowly, rather than pressuring yourself to “power through” long readings when your mind is exhausted.
4. When and Why to Seek Professional Counseling or Medication
When to seek counseling
Consider Christian counseling when:
- Emotional distress (anxiety, sadness, anger, fear, shame) is persistent and not easing.
- Symptoms interfere with basic life: work, sleep, relationships, responsibilities.
- You have past trauma (abuse, violence, sudden loss) that keeps resurfacing.
- You are engaging in self‑harm, suicidal thoughts, or dangerous behaviors.
- You feel “stuck” despite sincere spiritual efforts and support from friends/church.
Proverbs 20:5 says:
“The purpose in a man’s heart is like deep water, but a man of understanding will draw it out.”
God often uses wise, trained counselors to help draw out what feels confusing and tangled.
When to consider medication
Medication is not magic, and it’s not for everyone. But it can be part of wise care when:
- A qualified medical professional (preferably respectful of your faith) diagnoses a condition where medication is helpful (e.g., major depression, bipolar disorder, certain anxiety conditions, psychosis).
- Emotional/mental symptoms are so intense that you cannot engage in daily life, relationships, or spiritual practices.
- There is a family history suggesting a biological component.
Medication can:
- Lower the “volume” of symptoms so you can think, pray, and relate more clearly.
- Stabilize mood sufficiently to engage in counseling and spiritual growth.
Medication cannot:
- Save your soul
- Replace the gospel
- Remove all suffering in a broken world
But, under good medical care, it can be a gift of common grace.
If you’re unsure, talk with:
- A wise pastor
- A Christian counselor
- A trusted Christian physician/psychiatrist
Discernment, prayer, and good information matter here.
5. How Family and Church Can Support Without Over‑Spiritualizing
Those who suffer mentally and emotionally often feel alone. Family and church can be lifelines—or, unintentionally, heavy burdens.
Ways to support well
- Listen before fixing.
- “Help me understand what your days feel like.”
- “What is hardest right now?”
- “What would be one small way I could support you this week?”
- Validate their struggle.
- “What you’re experiencing is real and heavy, and I’m sorry.”
- “You are not crazy or faithless for feeling this way.”
- Pray with them and for them.
- Short, simple prayers—don’t preach in your prayer.
- Help with practical burdens.
- Meals, childcare, rides to appointments, help with routine tasks.
- Encourage wise help.
- Offer to help them find a counselor or see a doctor.
- Normalize getting help: “Many believers have walked this path and gotten good help.”
What to avoid
- Trite answers: “Just cheer up,” “Just trust God more,” “Others have it worse.”
- Misusing verses as band‑aids: throwing a verse to end the conversation instead of entering their sorrow.
- Shaming language: “You’re being ungrateful,” “Stop being so negative,” “Real Christians don’t…”.
- Over‑spiritualizing everything: Assuming every struggle is only demonic or only due to a specific hidden sin, without considering body and history.
Ray Ortlund describes a healthy church culture as:
“Gospel doctrine creating a gospel culture—where it’s safe to be honest because Jesus is our righteousness, not our performance.”
— Ray Ortlund, The Gospel (paraphrased)
We want homes and churches like that.
6. Pastoral Limits: What Pastors Can and Cannot Offer
Pastors and church leaders play a vital role—but they are not all‑purpose fixers.
What pastors can offer
- Preaching and teaching that shows Christ’s compassion for the weak and suffering.
- Prayer and spiritual guidance: helping people interpret their suffering in light of Scripture.
- Sacraments (baptism, Lord’s Supper) as tangible reminders of God’s promises.
- Basic pastoral counseling: listening, praying, offering biblical perspective, helping identify next steps.
- Referrals and partnerships with counselors, doctors, and support resources.
What pastors should not pretend to be
- Psychiatrists or physicians (unless they actually are)
- Trauma specialists or clinical psychologists (unless trained)
- Emergency mental health responders beyond their training
Ethically and lovingly, pastors:
- Should know their limits.
- Should refer people to qualified professionals when problems are complex, chronic, or dangerous.
- Should not shame members for seeing a counselor or doctor.
This is not failure; it is part of shepherding wisely.
David Powlison once remarked that good pastoral care often includes:
“Knowing when to walk with someone yourself and when to walk with them to someone else’s door.”
— David Powlison (paraphrased)
7. A Holistic View: Body, Mind, Soul, Relationships
God created you as an integrated whole:
- Body – hormones, brain chemistry, sleep, nutrition, physical health
- Mind – thoughts, perceptions, beliefs, understanding
- Soul/Spirit – relationship with God, worship, conscience, faith
- Relationships – family, friends, church, work, community
Trouble in one area affects the others.
For example:
- Chronic lack of sleep can magnify anxiety and dark thoughts.
- Trauma in relationships can shape how you see God and yourself.
- Unresolved guilt can weigh on your body (Psalm 32:3–4).
- Physical illness can lower mood and patience.
A holistic approach might include:
- Body:
- Sleep hygiene, exercise, medical checkups
- Considering medication if appropriate
- Mind:
- Counseling to address distorted thoughts, trauma, and patterns
- Learning new ways to respond to anxious or depressive thoughts
- Soul:
- Regular, honest prayer and lament
- Scripture meditation, worship, sacraments
- Confessing sin where needed, and receiving grace
- Relationships:
- Leaning into safe friends and church community
- Setting boundaries with destructive people
- Reconciling where possible, with wisdom
Jesus came to redeem all of you, not only your “spiritual” parts:
“Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.”
(Matthew 11:28)
That invitation includes mental and emotional burdens.
8. Recommended Christian Books for Further Study
On mental health and the Christian life
- Edward T. Welch – Blame It on the Brain?
A thoughtful, accessible look at when problems are physical, spiritual, or both, and how to respond biblically. - Edward T. Welch – Depression: Looking Up from the Stubborn Darkness
Honest, biblical, compassionate help for depression. - Zack Eswine – Spurgeon’s Sorrows: Realistic Hope for Those Who Suffer from Depression
Uses Charles Spurgeon’s experience to bring comfort and gospel hope. - Amy Simpson – Troubled Minds: Mental Illness and the Church’s Mission
A powerful call for churches to care wisely for those with mental illness.
On anxiety, fear, and emotions
- Ed Welch – Running Scared: Fear, Worry, and the God of Rest
Biblical help for worry and anxiety. - Paul David Tripp – Awe or New Morning Mercies
Daily reflections that speak into both heart and emotions.
On trauma, suffering, and God’s presence
- Diane Langberg – Suffering and the Heart of God
Deep, wise, and compassionate teaching on trauma and God’s care. - Timothy Keller – Walking with God through Pain and Suffering
A rich theology of suffering, very relevant to long-term emotional and mental pain.
On caring as a church
- Ray Ortlund – The Gospel: How the Church Portrays the Beauty of Christ
On building church cultures that are safe for struggling people. - Paul David Tripp – Instruments in the Redeemer’s Hands
How ordinary believers can walk with one another in wise, compassionate ways.
A Closing Pastoral Prayer for the Mentally and Emotionally Weary
Father of mercies,
You see the one who is tired in mind and heart.
You know the racing thoughts, the heavy mornings, the tears no one else sees.Thank You that You do not despise weakness
and that Your Son was “a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief.”For those who are confused: give gentle clarity.
For those who are ashamed: remind them they are not alone and not beyond Your love.
For those who need help: provide wise counselors, caring doctors, and supportive friends.Teach Your church to be a safe place for honest struggle,
where Christ’s compassion is visible and tangible.Hold this dear one fast when they feel like they are slipping.
Let Your Word be an anchor,
Your Spirit a Comforter,
Your people a shelter,
and Your Son their refuge and rest.In the name of Jesus, our gentle and lowly Savior, Amen.
Visit our companion site
Discover the Truth About Jesus Christ
Are you new to the Christian faith or seeking answers about Jesus? Visit JesusIsLordBlog.com for insightful articles, compelling reasons to believe, and a deeper understanding of what it means to follow Jesus as Lord and Savior. Start your journey today!
